z-kolkiemz-kolkiem

Why home biases may be bad

A home bias means holding a higher proportion of investments in your domestic financial markets than is justified by that market’s size. And many investors have far higher levels of assets invested in the UK than its global capitalisation in any asset class warrants. James Robertson highlights the reasons why this may be a bad approach.
Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on email
Published 17 September
7 mins

There is always a healthy debate among investors: what is the right thing to do versus what is comfortable. Sometimes the two outcomes align and the course an investor should follow is the one taken and there is a minimal level of discomfort. Other times, however, the choices we make as investors are governed by emotions, even if we won’t acknowledge this.

One area in which feelings often sway actions is where investors consciously, or subconsciously, weight significant percentages of their portfolio to their home market. Falling within the umbrella of familiarity bias, many investors around the world are culpable of favouritism for certain stocks over others that may require a bit more work to select. The bias is prevalent in so many of the decisions we make on a daily basis with regard to our favourite brands and, as we use the same decision-making process for less frequent choices, why wouldn’t we drift towards the stock selections behind the choices we enjoy all the time? Some may even believe their spending alone is propping up the share price!

These preferences are also relatively easily validated given we are more likely to hear or read what’s happening with the firm(s) on a regular basis in the local or national news outlets. Since Warren Buffet is often quoted as advocating that we should invest in businesses we understand, where better to invest in those companies we know?

There is also another argument advocated for UK investors in particular with regard to home bias, given significant sums invested locally are in companies that are part of the FTSE 100 index. Although the names are technically domestic investments, the reality is that typically 70-80% of these companies’ earnings are from overseas activities. These stocks are not, therefore, reliant on our local fortunes and, instead, should act as a useful counterpoint to changes in the value of Sterling. The argument is that if the value of Sterling has risen and our imports cost more, FTSE 100 companies should see the value of their overseas earnings increase too. This money is passed to investors via the regular dividends UK companies usually pay out, which drives higher share prices, and, in the end, should balance out the higher bills.

The reality is that home bias worked well for the industry a couple of decades ago when overseas investing was difficult given we could lean in to investors’ pre-existing biases.

Since then, however, investing overseas has become easier. At the same time, the benefits of globalisation have advanced and we may realise we are missing out on a similar opportunity that yields more. The brands we buy on the high street and online aren’t just ones from the UK either. It leads people to question why we would invest in a home-grown company, when we can invest in the best company in that sector regardless of its jurisdiction.

As a result of these and other changes, the average proportion of assets that UK-managed equity funds invest at home fell from around 50% on average a decade ago to just below 30% in 2020. Many believe investors should go further and only invest in the UK what it’s global market capitalisation warrants – between 4-5% of an equity portfolio – not least as UK stocks have underperformed their peers in recent years as shown by the below table:

 % change
 

YTD

1YR

3YR

5YR

FTSE All Share

13.33

24.95

3.93

5.62

Euro Stoxx 50

19.84

28.85

11.22

9.82

S&P500

19.89

35.52

17.81

18.12

Japan Topix

17.24

31.53

9.96

11.74

MSCI Asia Pacific

1.39

20.99

12.47

11.28

MSCI Emerging Markets

3.03

23.33

11.82

10.37

Source: Bloomberg as at each market close on 10 September 2021.

But why is it then that investment managers still introduce home bias as if it were a good thing?

It is our experience, however, that many of the arguments for a home bias are not actually linked to the bias per se, but instead because it is easy to confuse between approaches and outcomes, and especially in the case of the UK. Being rewarded for investing with a home bias often has nothing to do with the assets’ locality and everything to do with their underlying fundamentals.

Those who advocate for a home bias, for example, may try to argue that aligning your portfolio based on market capitalisation may mean you are investing less of your equity portfolio in the UK than in, say, a single tech name in the US. However, we believe this is very unlikely to be the case if your portfolio is properly diversified across asset classes, geographies, industries and investment styles.

Instead, whether you are based in the UK or not, even holding 4-5% of your equity allocation in UK stocks may have been too much since the global financial crisis given that there is a far larger proportion of cyclical and value stocks versus growth stocks (such as communication services and technology) in UK indices versus our financial market peers, and particularly when we compare the UK’s FTSE 100 to the US’s S&P 500. As cyclical and value stocks have underperformed other styles, we should not conclude that the UK is good or bad based on its status as home market for some investors, but due to its stock market composition.

This make up should be borne in mind now the global recovery is underway. Any increases in UK investments should also not be assigned to an increasing preference for what’s comfortable. Instead, investors should reconsider their UK holdings because, at this point in the economic cycle, cyclical and value stocks traditionally outperform growth stocks, and its stocks are rebounding off far more reasonable valuations than their peers around the world.

You should also reconsider UK holdings now, again not because they are UK stocks per se, but because they have tended to provide better protection against any unexpected bursts of inflation. This is because lots of UK stocks regularly pay out dividends and, although many cut or stopped their dividends in 2020 due to the pandemic – wisely choosing to retain cash against unforeseen events and uncertainties – many pay-outs have now restarted and these should grow in line with domestic pricing power. Incidentally, value and cyclical stocks have also tended to do well when inflation is on the increase. Since inflationary fear is stalking investors in other parts of the world too, not just in the UK, and dividends can mitigate the effects of rising prices regardless of their source, it gives us another reason to investment more in the FTSE All Share Index.

Last but not least, although it may not feel like it, much of the uncertainty linked to Brexit is behind us, as is some of the uncertainty linked to the pandemic. With one of the highest levels of vaccinated populations in the world (and access to more vaccines and the science behind them), yet again there are more reasons for more investors to put more money in UK stocks.

It was against this backdrop, therefore, that Nedbank Private Wealth chose to increase its allocation to the UK. It was not a reversal of our view on home bias – which we still believe to be flawed – but based on careful research that highlighted all the reasons for the UK stock market to enjoy a better period than in previous years.

We still, therefore, advise against a home bias for clients because many of their other assets are denominated in their home currency. If, for UK clients, your house, car and culturally-led chattels already mean you have a significant percentage of your assets in Sterling, why would you again choose to overweight the UK in your investment portfolios given we intrinsically understand the importance of diversification?

And for those still wanting to promote home bias as an investment approach? I would only ask you enquire as to whether the investment house in question can manage currency risks. Lots of investment firms can’t and, therefore, continue to push investment fundamental stories as reasons to back a bias. With currency management in place, investors are able to invest based on the most compelling investment case alone – regardless of location – and without confusing the reasons why. And, unlike the difficulties in accessing global brands physically due to the many supply chain issues, we continue to invest on behalf of clients globally based on the very best opportunities we, and our underlying managers, uncover.

Clients of Nedbank Private Wealth can get in touch with their private banker directly to understand how their portfolios are responding to market events, or call +44 (0)1624 645000 to speak to our client services team.

 

If you would like to find out more about how we manage clients’ investments, please contact us on the same number as above. Or you can get in touch using the links to the forms towards the end of this page.

Sources: Nedbank Private Wealth; and Bloomberg

The value of investments can fall, as well as rise, and you might not get back the original amount invested. Exchange rate changes affect the value of investments. Past performance is not necessarily a guide to future returns. Any individual investment or security mentioned may be included in clients’ portfolios and is referenced for illustrative purposes only, not as a recommendation, not least as it may not be suitable. You should always seek professional advice before making any investment decisions.

about the author

James Robertson

James Robertson

Based in our Isle of Man office, James is responsible for delivering the end-to-end investment management process, overseeing the implementation of the Nedbank Private Wealth house view within our discretionary managed portfolios, and for developing our investment proposition.

 

He has over 18 years’ investment experience and has been responsible for the Nedbank Private Wealth managed discretionary portfolios since 2007. James holds the Certificate in Investment Performance Measurement from the CFA Institute.

Access more of our insights

Investing

Options for uncertain investors

19 Oct

   |   7½ mins

Many clients hesitate to invest. They have often realised the reasons why, but want to hold back given we live in uncertain times. Rebecca Cretney highlights the points she raises in her conversations, as well as the advantages and disadvantages for the options to be considered.

Investing

The week in review

19 Oct

   |   5½ mins

The week of 11 October saw inflation increase higher than had been expected in the US and raised the prospects of action by the Federal Reserve in its November meeting. Meanwhile, growth forecasts for developed markets were cut slightly as supply chain issues continue.

Investing

September's investment market commentary

18 Oct

   |   2 mins

During September, the economic and corporate environment remained positive, however some equity sectors are beginning to look fully valued.

Investing

The week in review

12 Oct

   |   5½ mins

The week of 4 October saw persistent inflation amid signs of slowing economic growth, with fears of stagflation stoked. While the US announced a disappointing new job number for September, but a fall in unemployment.

Get in touch

If you are interested in becoming a client, please complete the form via the ‘become a client’ button below. Alternatively, if you are already a client, or if you have a question about how we help clients in particular circumstances, please use the ‘contact us’ button.

 

We will get back to you as soon as we can during office hours, which are Monday to Friday, 8am to 8pm (UK time), except for UK public holidays.

Become a Client

Thank you for your interest in Nedbank Private Wealth. Please call us on +44 (0)1624 645000 or complete the requested information and one of our team will get back to you soon. We look forward to speaking with you.  Please note: If you are an EU resident, we are unfortunately unable to offer our services to you at present.

* Required fields

Contact Us

Please call us today on +44 (0)1624 645000. Our office hours are weekdays from 8am to 8pm (UK time), except for UK public holidays.

 

Or please complete and submit the below form and one of the team will get back to you as requested.

* Required fields

Search suggestions